I recently received the following letter.
Dear Dr. Mains,
I’m a member of the Search Committee for our church. We’re looking for a new minister. For the first time in my life, I’m having to evaluate the preaching of different candidates, and I confess that I don’t really know what I’m listening for. My suspicion is that I’m not the only one on the committee with this problem. Can you help me?
Sincerely,
L.C.
Quick answer: Of course! I’ll gladly help you!
After listening to a candidate’s sermon, the Search Committee should be able to quickly answer the following questions:
- What was the sermon subject? Re-said, what was the main topic the minister was talking about? (This is not the same question as “what was the text.”) The committee should soon be able to come to agreement on this.
- What was the desired response? What did the minister want the people to do or stop doing? Once again, the answer should quickly be clear to everyone on the committee.
- What practical suggestions did the preacher make as to how to accomplish this objective? Good preaching is not just informational, but transformational. Did the committee feel the people listening were now capable of putting into practice what was suggested?
- Did the sermon address the time factor? “To pull off the desired response should take approximately (this long).” Ministers have a tendency to feel that people can change much faster than is normal. Did the committee believe the matter of time was fairly addressed?
Regardless of other sermon-related matters, if none of these four questions were answered, you should look for someone else!
If two of the four questions were addressed to the satisfaction of the committee, then this preacher has real potential. Keep him or her on the list of possibilities.
If the Search Committee agrees that more than two of the questions were covered, you have a terrific communicator in your sights. If he or she passes your other tests, make as good an offer as possible, as soon as possible, and pray like mad for a positive response!
———————————————
Pastor, when “sermon prep day” rolls around each week, do you face the task of preparing another sermon with a frown on your face? If so, you’re not alone. Many pastors literally dread preparing their Sunday sermon. There just doesn’t seem to be an easy solution. The good news: David Mains and Mainstay Ministries can help. We offer a wide variety of Sermon Starters and Full Sermons that will give you Sermon Ideas to help you prepare for regular Sunday sermons, Mid-week Bible Sermons, and Sermons for special occasions. We also offer assistance as you create Topical Sermons, Sermons Series, and sermons for special times of the year. We have resources available to help you with Advent Celebrations, Advent Sermons, Christmas Sermons, Easter Sunday Sermons, Patriotic Sermons, and more.
For more information on how to create better Bible Sermons and how to turn Sermon Ideas into Sermon Outlines, and then into effective, meaningful Sunday Sermons, please click here to visit David Mains’ website.
You will also find a variety of resources for pastors and congregations at the Mainstay Ministries website. Just click here.